Oral arguments today in a federal appeals court case brought by the AHA, Association of American Medical Colleges, America’s Essential Hospitals and three hospital organizations to challenge a nearly 30% reduction to Medicare payments for 340B drugs focused on procedure issues. However, as evidenced by questions from the judges, the court seemed most interested in whether the Medicare statute expressly precludes judicial review of the Department of Health and Human Services’ actions. The attorney representing the government argued that the Congress clearly intended to preclude review, arguing that the specific section relied on to make the payment reduction was “mushed up together” in the section of the law that authorized preclusion. The attorney for the AHA and other plaintiffs argued forcefully that evidence of preclusion must be clear and convincing and that the preclusion provision identifies only specific statutory sections that are shielded from review, including sections added to law after the addition of the section at issue in the case. There also was discussion of whether plaintiffs had adequately presented their claims to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services and whether CMS had the legal authority to reduce reimbursement to section 340B hospitals by almost 30% under the section of the statute establishing the reimbursement methodology for separately payable outpatient prospective payment system drugs. The AHA hopes for a ruling from the court sometime this summer. To listen to a recording of today’s oral arguments, click here
 

Related News Articles

Headline
The AHA today debuted a new video that spotlights the value of membership in the AHA, including how the association is telling hospital and health systems’…
Headline
The AHA has been featured in numerous media publications, including the Washington Post, Wall Street Journal, Politico and Modern Healthcare, for various COVID…
Blog
The AHA strives to ensure the hospital and health system field’s voice is heard in the news and media and any discussion of health care. The association…
Headline
In light of the latest novel coronavirus (COVID-19) developments and the unprecedented and still growing demand for health care, construction and architecture…
Headline
In light of the latest novel coronavirus (COVID-19) developments and the need for nursing leaders to remain onsite in their essential roles, the AHA and its…
Chairperson's File
Hospitals and health systems are working to address their patients’ social needs and the broader social determinants of health in the communities they serve.…