The AHA and Federation of American Hospitals today urged the U.S. Supreme Court to review a federal appeals court decision that allows False Claims Act whistleblowers to accuse a hospital or other defendant of fraud and proceed to discovery without articulating specific facts demonstrating the circumstances or scope of the alleged fraud.
 
“The question here is whether private plaintiffs pursuing FCA claims should have to follow the same basic rules of civil litigation that apply to every other plaintiff pursuing a fraud claim, or whether they should be treated as a special class of plaintiff entitled to a court-made exception from those rules,” the associations said in a friend-of-the-court brief filed in the case. “Amici and their members submit that they should not be. … The Tenth Circuit’s relaxed standard strips away the protections [Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 9(b)] affords other defendants. Discovery in FCA cases can be enormously expensive, even when it confirms that the relator could not plead the circumstances of any fraud because no fraud occurred. For all hospitals, the costs are an unnecessary diversion of resources from patient care; for community hospitals in particular, these consequences can be devastating. This Court should grant certiorari to restore the consistent application of the plain text of Rule 9(b) in all fraud cases, including those brought under the FCA.”
 

Related News Articles

Headline
The House of Representatives last night voted 419-6 to pass legislation (H.R. 748) that would repeal the 40% excise tax on high-value employer-sponsored health…
Headline
The ERISA Industry Committee has withdrawn its support for legislation approved yesterday by the House Energy and Commerce Committee to address surprise…
Headline
The House Energy and Commerce Committee today approved legislation to address surprise medical bills and Medicaid disproportionate share hospital cuts.
Headline
Congress should pass legislation that would protect patients from surprise medical bills; preserve the ability of providers and insurers to negotiate private…
Headline
The House Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Health today passed the No Surprises Act (H.R. 3630), bipartisan legislation that would prohibit balance billing…
Headline
The House Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Health tomorrow is scheduled to mark up 10 health-related bills, including the No Surprises Act — bipartisan…