Responding today to a Federal Trade Commission request for comments on the impact of certificates of public advantage, AHA takes no position on COPA laws but says the drive for states to enact them and for hospitals to obtain COPAs might diminish if the agency were to credit efficiency claims by merging hospitals more often. The Horizontal Merger Guidelines indicate that the FTC and Department of Justice will credit efficiencies in an antitrust analysis, but many merging hospitals have found that promise “chimerical,” AHA wrote. As a result, many state legislatures and hospitals have concluded that a COPA process “is preferable to an antitrust review that focuses narrowly on competition to the near exclusion of all other considerations,” AHA said.
 
In separate comments submitted to FTC, health care consulting firm Kaufman, Hall & Associates said “competition-based approaches are unlikely to prove effective in lowering costs, promoting efficient resource allocation, and improving quality and access to markets where acute inpatient capacity significantly exceeds the needs of the population.”
 
FTC will hold a public workshop June 18 in Washington, D.C., to assess the impact of COPAs on health care prices, quality, access and innovation.

Related News Articles

Headline
Ian Morrison, a highly regarded author, consultant and futurist, died last week. He specialized in long-term forecasting and planning with a particular…
Headline
To navigate a shifting landscape of technologies, care models and patient needs, hospitals and health systems need to develop future leaders who are ready to…
Blog
I’ve met so many remarkable health care professionals — leaders who wake up each day determined to navigate a shifting landscape of technologies, care models…
Headline
A report released Jan. 9 by Kaufman Hall highlights hospital and health system merger and acquisition activity from last year.  The report said that…
Chairperson's File
From making pizzas to leading an integrated health system, Tina Freese Decker’s career has focused on a connection to people and serving others. She is…
Headline
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce Jan. 13 filed a lawsuit against the Federal Trade Commission, saying changes made by the FTC to premerger notification rules under…