A federal appeals court today heard oral arguments in the government’s appeal of its loss in a legal challenge to the 2019 reduction in site neutral payment brought by the AHA, joined by the Association of American Medical Colleges and several AHA member hospitals.

The judges questioned counsel for the government on its assertion of broad authority under the Medicare statute to take an action it says was designed specifically as a method to control an unnecessary increase in the volume of services provided in a hospital-based outpatient clinic that could be provided less expensively in a physician-office, as well as its assertion that the statute shielded its action from judicial oversight.

Counsel for AHA, AAMC and the hospitals forcefully countered that the government’s broad assertion of authority and its attempt to shield its action from review by the court was not aligned with the statute nor consistent with the agency’s previous view of what the statute permitted. 

Counsel also pointed out that Congress explicitly considered exactly the concern that the agency asserted it was addressing by making the payment reduction and made a different choice to ensure that higher payments for certain excepted facilities continued under the existing payment system.

Related News Articles

Headline
The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services June 30 issued its calendar year 2026 proposed rule for the home health prospective payment system. This rule…
Headline
The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services today announced it has identified a fraud scheme targeting Medicare providers and suppliers. CMS said scammers…
Headline
A report released June 17 by NORC at the University of Chicago, commissioned by the Coalition to Strengthen America’s Healthcare, found that patients enrolled…
Headline
The Medicare Payment Advisory Commission June 13 released its June report to Congress that outlines recommendations for hospital and other Medicare payment…
Headline
The AHA commented to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services June 10 on the fiscal year 2026 inpatient prospective payment system proposed rule (https…
Headline
The AHA expressed concerns (LINK) to the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services today on payment updates for the fiscal year 2026 proposed rule for the…