Analysis finds bias in CMS's overall hospital star ratings methodology

Jul 06, 2016 - 05:49 PM

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services’ approach to overall hospital quality star ratings appears to have several shortcomings, according to a new analysis by an expert in econometrics, commissioned by the AHA. “While it appears to give the impression of being rigorous and objective the estimation aspect is highly dependent on choice of measures and the weighting scheme is entirely subjective and highly determinant of the final outcomes,” writes Francis Vella, chair of the Department of Economics at Georgetown University, among other concerns. Commenting on the study, AHA President and CEO Rick Pollack said, “Patients need reliable information to make important choices regarding their health care. And hospitals and health systems need reliable information so that they can continue to improve the quality of the care delivered. CMS star ratings misses the mark on both accounts.” CMS delayed the release of the ratings in April after AHA and 285 members of Congress raised concerns about the agency’s methodology.

Related News Articles

Blog
Launching a National Effort to Improve Postpartum Hemorrhage Outcomes
h2, h3, h4 {color: #002855;} Postpartum hemorrhage (PPH) is one of the most common — and preventable — causes of maternal health in the United States. The…
Chairperson's File
Chair File: Leadership Dialogue — Innovation in Patient Safety with Amy Rockman of the AI Center of Excellence
Public
For decades, hospitals and health systems have used innovation to improve patient care and outcomes. We have seen dramatic improvements and know we can never…
Headline
AHA celebrates Patient Safety Awareness Week 
March 8-14 marks Patient Safety Awareness Week. The AHA has several resources including podcasts, videos and reports that show how AHA members are advancing…
Headline
Florida district court rules Leapfrog used deceptive practices for hospital safety rating system
The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida March 6 ruled in favor of five Florida hospitals in a case challenging the methodology used by the…
Chairperson's File
Chair File: Hospital Teams Across the Country Are Advancing Patient Safety
Public
This week, March 8-14, is Patient Safety Awareness Week. Delivering safe, quality care to all patients is the top priority for everyone working in hospitals…
Headline
FDA issues most serious recall for certain glucose monitor sensors
The Food and Drug Administration has identified a Class I recall of certain FreeStyle Libre 3 and FreeStyle Libre 3 Plus…