A new study out today conflicts head on with an April 2015 study by a leading health care expert and antitrust economist that found “concentration or structure alone is not a meaningful or reliable predictor of price changes.”  Both studies relied on commercial data, but the latter had authors who were better able to understand how the field actually functions and interpret the data accordingly.

Today’s study suffers from many deficiencies, including a lack of data from the Blue Cross insurers that dominate most markets across the country.  That flaw alone merits serious skepticism about the conclusions.  More than that, in a field as dynamic as health care, relying on data from 2007-2011 seems like old news. It certainly doesn’t account for the many reasons that hospitals have sought partners since then, including the need for capital to improve quality and, in many case, keep the doors open to their communities. 

It’s important to note that the author’s prior studies that relied on Medicare data are, at best, suspect and likely unreliable and that the insurers involved, two of which are attempting to merge with each other, don’t appear to be passing any savings from lower costs on to consumers in the form of more affordable premiums.

Today’s study does nothing to advance our understanding of how we can move health care to the next level by improving quality, efficiency, affordability and convenience.  

Related News Articles

Headline
At an AHA forum today in Atlanta, hospital and health system leaders shared insights and explored opportunities and challenges for driving innovation and value…
Blog
In this AHA Stat Blog, Priya Bathija, vice president of AHA’s The Value Initiative, writes that, while high-tech innovations are significant, we must not…
Headline
The AHA and the Puerto Rico Hospital Association today hosted a forum where hospital and health system leaders spotlighted the connection between quality…
Chairperson's File
There is no doubt that enhanced convenience and customer service is where health care is headed.
Blog
In this AHA Stat Blog post, Priya Bathija, vice president of AHA’s The Value Initiative, shares how hospitals and health systems have made substantial efforts…
Headline
AHA Board Chairman Brian Gragnolati today kicked off the AHA Rural Health Care Leadership Conference by welcoming more than 900 rural hospital and health…