A report released last month used commercial claims data from United Healthcare (United), Aetna and Humana to reach a number conclusions about hospital prices and concentration. The paper is badly flawed and the assertions made about hospital market structure and prices, in particular, should be viewed as unreliable for a number of reasons.  The data used are old (2008-2011) and predate the effects of public and some private payers shifting to value-based payments. Here are a few key issues with the study:

  • There are no claims data from the Blue Cross Blue Shield plans even though they dominate the insurance market in at least 40 states and even more numerous metropolitan areas.
  • The commercial claims data used in the study are from just three insurance companies, one of which, Humana, has only 30 percent of its enrollment mix in commercial products.
    • To illustrate the distortions attributable to this severely limited data set, consider the impact on just two states mentioned in the paper.  According to the most recent American Medical Association data for:
      • Colorado -- half of the markets (MSAs) are dominated by plans other than United, Aetna or Humana.  Neither Aetna nor Humana is listed as either the first or second largest insurer in the state.
      • Minnesota -- the Blue plan dominates every market and Medica is listed as number two. 

For a more in-depth analysis on the report by a leading health care economist click here.

Related News Articles

Insights and Analysis
AHA Today recently caught up with Priya Bathija to discuss the first year of the initiative, what resources and learnings are planned for 2019 and how its work…
Headline
The AHA today hosted the second day of its executive forum during which hospital and health system leaders shared strategies for innovating to enhance value…
Headline
The AHA today in Chicago hosted the latest in a series of regional forums at which hospital and health system leaders shared strategies for innovating to…
Perspective
Earlier this month, voters in exit poll after exit poll made it clear that health care is an important issue to them. And near the top of their list of…
Insights and Analysis
Affordability is a top priority for the AHA, writes Chair-elect Brian Gragnolati. And we will continue our forward-thinking and leaning-in approach as we…
Chairperson's File
The Members in Action series, part of AHA’s The Value Initiative, highlights how hospitals and health systems are implementing new value-based strategies to…