Statement on Health Care Competition Report

Tom Nickels
Executive Vice President
American Hospital Association

December 3, 2018

America’s hospitals and health systems embrace a competitive health care landscape, thereby increasing opportunities for consumers to get the care they need. Based on our initial read, we are pleased by several of the proposals put forth in today’s report, such as those to broaden providers’ scope of practice and expand access to telehealth, which will improve access to care for patients.

At the same time, we strongly oppose attempts to loosen the current restrictions on physician-owned hospitals. The Congressional Budget Office, Medicare Payment Advisory Commission and independent researchers have concluded that physician self-referral to facilities in which they have an ownership stake leads to greater per capita utilization of services and higher costs for the Medicare program. Further, physician-owned hospitals tend to cherry-pick the most profitable patients, jeopardizing communities’ access to full-service care. This trend creates a destabilizing environment that leaves sicker and less-affluent patients to community hospitals, threatening the health care safety net. We also oppose the restructuring of graduate medical education (GME) funding that would result in less federal support for physician training. We also have serious concerns regarding proposals to weaken insurance protections for patients, and any expansion of site-neutral policies. On interoperability, we look forward to working with the Administration on steps that would make it easier to share health information to engage patients and provide the best possible care without increasing regulatory burdens.

We look forward to working with the Administration and other stakeholders to further accelerate progress in access and affordability to better serve patients.




Colin Milligan, (202) 638-5491

Marie Johnson, (202) 626-2351

Related Resources

Action Alert
The Department of Homeland Security’s recent proposed rule could limit legal immigrants’ future immigration status based on their receipt of public
Bibliography/Link Page
Newsletter from December 2018 highlighting AHA resources, advocacy updates, and more regarding behavioral health.
Special Bulletin
Special Bulletin on CMS’s Nov. 26 proposed rule aimed at lowering drug prices for beneficiaries enrolled in Medicare Advantage and Part D programs.
AHA Center for Health Innovation Market Scan
The rapid rise of telehealth services has spawned a new academic fellowship at Jefferson Health, which includes Philadelphia University and Thomas Jefferson…
The AHA urges the Health Resources and Services Administration to meet the Jan. 1 effective date it has proposed for its final rule on drug ceiling prices and…
Special Bulletin
The CMS, Nov. 8 released a proposed rule that would make changes to the Medicaid and Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP) managed care regulations and,…